| 39 | Bill James | Madison · Jan. 10, 1969 |
| 39 | Rick Stultz | West Washington · Nov. 29, 1969 |
| 38 | Mark McCullough | Charlestown · Jan. 14, 1916 |
| 38 | Bill James | Franklin · Jan. 25, 1969 |
| 38 | Bill James | Vincennes · Mar. 15, 1969 |
| 38 | Rick Stultz | Charlestown · Dec. 5, 1969 |
| 38 | Mike Sears | Seymour · Feb. 21, 1973 |
| 37 | LaVerne Altemeyer | Muncie Central · Mar. 10, 1956 |
| 37 | Vince Bruce | Austin · 1973–74 |
| 37 | Kody Clancy | South Decatur · Feb. 6, 2024 |
| 36 | Jack Owens | Salem · Dec. 22, 1965 |
| 36 | Jordan Taylor | Bedford North Lawrence · Feb. 2, 2008 |
| 35 | Bill James | Austin · Dec. 19, 1967 |
| 35 | Tony Lord | Madison · Jan. 7, 1972 |
| 35 | Chris Dunn | Clarksville · Jan. 24, 1992 |
| 35 | Dustin Yocum | Mitchell · Feb. 26, 2016 |
| 35 | Mitchell Meagher | Madison · Jan. 6, 2017 |
| 34 | Bill James | Jennings Co. · Feb. 27, 1969 |
| 34 | Vince Bruce | Mitchell · Feb. 1, 1975 |
| 34 | Bret Johnson | Columbus East · Dec. 20, 1977 |
| 34 | Bret Johnson | Floyd Central · Feb. 17, 1978 |
| 34 | Elmer Smith | Clarksville · Apr. 1, 1978 |
| 33 | Ralph Vannoy | Charlestown · Dec. 18, 1959 |
| 33 | Bill James | Franklin · Jan. 21, 1967 |
| 33 | Bill James | Salem · Jan. 12, 1968 |
| 33 | Rick Stultz | Floyd Central · Dec. 30, 1969 |
| 33 | Ted Murphy | Madison · Jan. 8, 1971 |
| 32 | Bill James | Martinsville · Mar. 8, 1969 |
| 32 | Gary Napier | Lanesville · 1975 |
| 32 | Bret Johnson | Floyd Central · Apr. 1, 1978 |
| 32 | Chuck Souder | Charlestown · Dec. 6, 1985 |
| 32 | Chuck Souder | Silver Creek · 1985–86 |
| 32 | Bobby Coomer | Jeffersonville · Jan. 23, 1988 |
| 32 | Chad Marley | Austin · Mar. 3, 1990 |
| 32 | Stephen Lewis | Austin · Nov. 1998 |
| 32 | Jared Comer | Maconaquah · Dec. 31, 2004 |
| 32 | Kody Clancy | Austin · Nov. 22, 2023 |
| 32 | Jack Miller | South Bend St. Joseph · Mar. 30, 2024 |
| 31 | Bill James | Austin · Nov. 22, 1967 |
| 31 | Bill James | Seymour · Feb. 24, 1968 |
| 31 | Bill James | Austin · Nov. 27, 1968 |
| 31 | Bill James | Silver Creek · Feb. 14, 1969 |
| 31 | Bill James | Brazil · Mar. 8, 1969 |
| 31 | Tony Lord | Floyd Central · Dec. 20, 1971 |
| 31 | Tony Lord | Jennings Co. · Jan. 29, 1971 |
| 31 | Vince Bruce | Corydon · Dec. 20, 1974 |
| 31 | Vince Bruce | Floyd Central · Jan. 4, 1975 |
| 31 | Vince Bruce | Salem · Jan. 17, 1975 |
| 31 | Vince Bruce | Silver Creek · Feb. 14, 1975 |
| 31 | Dustin Marshall | New Albany · Jan. 17, 2004 |
| 31 | Jared Comer | Floyd Central · Feb. 14, 2006 |
| 31 | Tony Amick | Clarksville · Jan. 19, 2007 |
| 31 | Brad Bowling | Southwestern (Hanover) · Feb. 4, 2011 |
| 31 | Mitchell Prince | Southwestern (Hanover) · Feb. 18, 2017 |
| 31 | Mitchell Prince | Southwestern (Hanover) · Feb. 17, 2018 |
| 30 | Kenny Wolf | Salem · Nov. 24, 1959 |
| 30 | Mike Carter | Salem · 1964 |
| 30 | Mike Carter | Silver Creek · Feb. 12, 1965 |
| 30 | Mike Carter | Austin · 1965 Sectional |
| 30 | Bill James | Southwestern · Nov. 8, 1968 |
| 30 | Bill James | Clarksville · Jan. 24, 1969 |
| 30 | Vince Bruce | Madison Shawe · Feb. 7, 1975 |
| 30 | Daniel Watson | Salem · Jan. 11, 2002 |
| 30 | Nicholas Sebastiao | Switzerland Co · Feb. 6, 2020 |
| 30 | Nicholas Sebastiao | West Washington · Feb. 8, 2020 |
| 30 | Nicholas Sebastiao | Southwestern · Feb. 22, 2020 |
| 30 | Hayden Cutter | Corydon Central · Dec. 18, 2020 |
| 30 | Hayden Cutter | Trinity Lutheran · Feb. 19, 2021 |
| 30 | Hayden Cutter | Austin · Nov. 24, 2021 |
| 30 | Jack Miller | North Harrison · Jan. 6, 2024 |
| 30 | Kody Clancy | Batesville · Mar. 9, 2024 |
| 30 | Garrett Boling | South Central · Feb. 8, 2025 |