| 39 | Taylor Means | vs. Clarksville (Jan. 7, 2016) |
| 38 | Pam Jones | vs. Mitchell (Dec. 4, 1975) |
| 38 | Patty Hutchinson | vs. Jennings County (Jan. 25, 1993) |
| 37 | Melinda Sparkman | vs. New Albany (Dec. 8, 1977) |
| 36 | Cindy Piet | vs. New Albany (Jan. 15, 1977) |
| 36 | Paige Barrett | vs. New Washington (Jan. 3, 2017) |
| 35 | Roxanne Cox | vs. Austin (Nov. 23, 1982) |
| 35 | Roxanne Cox | vs. Columbus East (Jan. 17, 1983) |
| 34 | Carrie Thompson | vs. Silver Creek (Nov. 26, 1990) |
| 34 | Katie Wampler | vs. Clarksville (Jan. 3, 2013) |
| 34 | Paige Barrett | vs. Christian Academy (Nov. 28, 2016) |
| 34 | Paige Barrett | vs. Clarksville (Jan. 7, 2017) |
| 33 | Rhonda Smith | vs. Silver Creek (Nov. 27, 1978) |
| 33 | Roxanne Cox | vs. New Albany (Feb. 12, 1983)* |
| 33 | Ellie Richardson | vs. Jeffersonville (Jan. 28, 2025) |
| 32 | Cindy Piet | vs. Charlestown (Dec. 8, 1975) |
| 32 | Cindy Piet | vs. Edgewood (Nov. 19, 1975) |
| 32 | Renee Westmoreland | vs. Columbus East (Jan. 1988) |
| 32 | Melanie Hughbanks | vs. Shawe Memorial (Jan. 31, 1991)* |
| 32 | Patty Hutchinson | vs. Charlestown (Dec. 6, 1993) |
| 32 | Patty Hutchinson | vs. Seymour (Jan. 22, 1994) |
| 32 | Andrea Rademacher | vs. Bedford North Lawrence (Jan. 6, 2007) |
| 32 | Paige Barrett | vs. McCutcheon (Dec. 29, 2016) |
| 32 | Paige Barrett | vs. Salem (Jan. 29, 2016) |
| 32 | Paige Barrett | vs. Salem (Jan. 12, 2017) |
| 32 | Ellie Richardson | vs. Gibson Southern (Feb. 17, 2024)* |
| 31 | Pam Jones | vs. Jac-Cen-Del (Mar. 7, 1974) |
| 31 | Roxanne Cox | vs. Jeffersonville (Jan. 26, 1983) |
| 31 | Renee Westmoreland | vs. Austin (Nov. 1988) |
| 31 | Carla Westmoreland | vs. Madison (Dec. 18, 1989) |
| 31 | Patty Hutchinson | vs. Columbus East (Jan. 29, 1994) |
| 30 | Cindy Piet | vs. Brownstown (Feb. 10, 1974) |
| 30 | Melinda Sparkman | vs. North Harrison (Nov. 16, 1978) |
| 30 | Roxanne Cox | vs. Jeffersonville (Jan. 27, 1982) |
| 30 | Roxanne Cox | vs. Southwestern (Feb. 4, 1982)* |
| 30 | Roxanne Cox | vs. North Harrison (Nov. 18, 1982) |
| 30 | Roxanne Cox | vs. Brownstown (Jan. 6, 1983) |
| 30 | Roxanne Cox | vs. Corydon (Feb. 12, 1983)* |
| 30 | Renee Westmoreland | vs. Benton Central (Feb. 25, 1989)* |
| 30 | Patty Hutchinson | vs. Floyd Central (Nov. 19, 1991) |
| 30 | Patty Hutchinson | vs. Jennings County (Jan. 27, 1992) |
| 30 | Patty Hutchinson | vs. New Albany (Dec. 10, 1992) |
| 30 | Zoe Zellers | vs. Connersville (Dec. 29, 2018) |
| 30 | Jaylah Mays | vs. Lawrenceburg (Dec. 29, 2018) |
| 30 | Jaylah Mays | vs. Clarksville (Jan. 9, 2020) |
| 30 | Ellie Richardson | vs. Columbus North (Dec. 27, 2024) |
| 30 | Ellie Richardson | vs. Eastern (Pekin) (Jan. 23, 2025) |